Delivery apps can bring you guests you'd never reach otherwise. They can also quietly turn a profitable kitchen into a busy one that loses money. The difference usually isn't the platform. It's how you set up your menu, your pricing and your operations for it.
We run our own delivery brands as well as consult on them, and the same lessons come up again and again. Here's how to approach Uber Eats, DoorDash and similar platforms so that every order earns its place.
Start with the real math
Before you change anything, understand what a delivery order is actually worth to you. For a typical order, start with the menu price and subtract:
- the platform commission, which depends on the plan you're on;
- packaging (container, lid, bag, cutlery, napkins, stickers);
- any promotion or discount you're funding;
- any ad spend attributed to that order;
- refunds and adjustments for missing or incorrect items;
- the food cost of the dish itself.
What's left is your contribution. Here's a purely illustrative example: a $20 dish with $6 of food cost, $1.50 of packaging and a commission in the region many restaurants report can leave a surprisingly thin margin before labour, rent or any promotions. Run this calculation with your own agreement and your own costs. Commission rates and plan options vary and change, so check your current contract rather than relying on what you've heard.
Once you see the numbers item by item, the rest of the strategy usually becomes obvious.
1. Build a dedicated delivery menu
Your dine-in menu was designed for plates, not bags. A delivery menu should be:
- Shorter. Fewer items means faster prep, fewer errors and less waste.
- Built for travel. Choose dishes that still look and taste good after 20 minutes in a bag. Crispy items, delicate sauces and anything assembled at the last second often struggle.
- Engineered for margin. Put your strongest-contribution items first, and use photos for every listing. On delivery apps, the photo often does the selling.
2. Price for the channel
Many restaurants price delivery items higher than dine-in to account for commission and packaging. Whether and how you do that depends on your platform agreement and your market, so read your contract carefully. If you do adjust, do it deliberately, item by item, based on your real contribution math rather than a flat across-the-board increase.
Bundles and combos can also help, by raising average order value while letting you control the mix.
3. Invest in packaging that protects the food
Good packaging costs more per order but often pays for itself through better ratings, fewer complaints and fewer refunds. Use vented containers for fried food, separate sauces from anything that can go soggy, and use tamper-evident seals. Include packaging in every item's cost, so you know exactly what each order costs you.
4. Treat promotions as experiments, not habits
Platforms make it easy to run discounts like a percentage off or free delivery. Some promotions genuinely bring new guests who come back. Others simply give a discount to people who would have ordered anyway.
Run promotions for a set period, then compare orders, average order value and, most importantly, total contribution against a normal period. If profit didn't improve, stop or change the offer.
5. Measure ads on profit, not orders
Sponsored listings can drive volume, but volume isn't the goal. Track what you spend on ads against the contribution from the orders they generate, not just the revenue. Start with a small budget, test a few items or time windows, and scale only what's clearly working.
6. Protect your ratings and reduce refunds
Ratings affect where you appear and whether people order. Missing items and wrong orders are the most common and most avoidable causes of bad reviews and refunds. A few habits help a lot:
- a printed checklist or label for every order, checked before sealing the bag;
- a dedicated packing station away from the line;
- clear modifier names in your POS and tablet, so cooks know exactly what was ordered.
Review your refunds and complaints weekly. Patterns, such as one dish that's often "missing" or one shift with more errors, tell you exactly where to fix the process. Where a refund was charged incorrectly, use the platform's dispute process.
7. Keep your menu availability accurate
Cancelling orders because an item has run out frustrates guests and can hurt your standing on the platform. Mark items unavailable as soon as you 86 them, and set realistic prep times, especially at peak. Pausing the tablet briefly during a crush is usually better than sending out late, poorly made food.
8. Be careful with virtual brands
Running several delivery-only brands from one kitchen can make good use of capacity, and many cloud kitchens do it successfully. But every brand adds menu complexity, inventory, listings to maintain and reviews to manage. Before adding a brand, check that it can share most of your existing ingredients and prep, and that you can track its sales and costs separately.
9. Build a direct channel too
Platforms are a great discovery tool, but you don't own the guest relationship. Where it makes sense, give regulars a reason to order directly, such as through your own website or by phone for pickup, so a portion of your volume isn't paying commission.
10. Review it monthly
Once a month, pull your delivery data and look at each item's contribution after all costs, your promotion and ad results, ratings and refunds. Small adjustments made regularly beat a big overhaul once a year.
The bottom line
Delivery can be a strong, profitable part of your business, but only if it's set up as its own channel with its own menu, prices and processes. The restaurants that do well on delivery are the ones that treat it as seriously as their dining room.
Our menu and operations services include delivery menu engineering, and our AI operations assistant can monitor ratings, complaints and availability across platforms for you. Want to talk it through? Book a free menu audit.